As we all know, cast iron is an efficient conductor of heat. What does this mean? Cast iron cookware may get hotter than what you’re used to with other cookware. Thus, traditional oven mitts may not be suitable.
You’re probably going to need an oven mitten recommended for use on cast iron cookware to ensure adequate heat protection. How do you choose the best oven mitts for cast iron? You should look for oven mitts with high heat resistance, non-slip, easy to maneuver, easy to wash, and preferably with wrist protection.
Generally, an oven mitt that can withstand the heat of 425 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit is desirable for use in cast iron cookware. Also, you have to consider the size as well. Even though a one-size-fits-all sounds like a practical choice, you may encounter gripping problems if the mitts’ size is too big or too small for you.
I know this information sounds too overwhelming, but don’t worry. I’ve gathered all the pertinent information you need to know when buying an oven mitt for cast iron. Here are the best oven mitts for cast iron in 2021 that should definitely be on your bucket list.
- Best Overall and Amazon’s Best Seller: HOMWE Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt
- Best Five-Fingered Oven Mitts: Loveuing Food-Grade Silicone Oven Mitt
- Most Heat-Resistant: RED LMLDETA Silicone Oven Hot Mitts
- Best Slip-Resistance: Gorilla Grip Resistant Silicone Oven Mitts
- Best One-Size-Fits-All Oven Mitts: GEEKHOM Silicone Oven Mitts
- Best Value Bundle: IXO 6Pcs Oven Mitts and Pot Holders
- Buying Guide: Oven Mitts for Cast Iron
- Final Words
Best Overall and Amazon’s Best Seller: HOMWE Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt
With nearly 32,000 sales on Amazon and many positive consumer reviews, we chose this oven mitt as the best overall.
Pros: Steam resistant, water-proof, machine-washable, flame-retardant, wrist protection
Cons: Too big for small-sized hands
Dimension: 14.7/13.7 inches
Silicone is a desirable material when it comes to handling hot cookware. That’s why most cast iron handle covers are silicone. The HOMWE Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt in particular won’t disappoint.
We particularly love these oven mitts for cast iron because of their great characteristics. Heat-resistance? 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which means it’s perfect when handling cast iron. Material? Superior silicon, which means it’s waterproof and steam-resistant. An oven glove that’s not waterproof is prone to moisture damage and that may destroy its integrity in the long term.
As for its length, it’s 14.7 inches long, which is long enough to include wrist protection. Furthermore, we love its stitched cotton border that aids in preventing your hands and wrists from getting burned.
You may notice its exterior design with its coarse and textured consistency. This design is not just for aesthetic purposes, but for preventing skidding or sliding when handling cast iron cookware as well. In addition, its interior is a mixture of cotton fabric and polyester material for better elasticity, comfort, and stability.
As for its product care instructions, it’s easy to clean by hand and also machine-washable. Since silicone mitts are stain-resistant, a little soap, warm water, and scrubbing will do the trick. If you plan to use the washing machine, you won’t have to worry about shrinkage or ripping.
Best Five-Fingered Oven Mitts: Loveuing Food-Grade Silicone Oven Mitt
This five-fingered oven mitt is a crowd favorite, thanks to its double-layer protection of 100% food-grade silicone material and multi-functional use.
Pros: Cool cotton inner lining, five-fingered gloves, convenient hook, versatile uses, available in different sizes and colors
Cons: Big provisions for fingers
Material: Exterior silicone, interior cloth, and cotton
Dimension: One-size-fits-all, small to 3XL
If you prefer a five-fingered oven mitt, then we recommend the Loveuing Food-Grade Silicone Oven Mitt. The outer layer is 100% food-grade silicone that’s waterproof and is heat resistant at 425 degrees Fahrenheit.
Its inner lining is soft jersey cotton that ensures your hand remains cool with maximum comfort while in use. Furthermore, it has a double protection layer for extra heat protection as compared to regular gloves.
What we love most about the Loveuing Food-Grade Silicone Oven Mitt is its multipurpose trait. Aside from handling hot cast iron pans, you can use them when grilling, washing vegetables, opening canned goods, or other household chores. It does not only serve as an oven mitt but as an all-around household glove to protect your hands.
In addition, its rough exterior surface allows great gripping and avoids slipping when handling cookware. Also, it has a convenient hook for comfortable storage. All in all, this five-fingered oven glove is great for use, especially in the busy kitchen.
You don’t want to remove and put on your oven mitts from time to time, right? From cleaning a vegetable to searing a steak in a cast iron pan, you can get through the whole cooking time without removing the Loveuing Food-Grade Silicone Oven Mitt.
Most Heat-Resistant: RED LMLDETA Silicone Oven Hot Mitts
Impressed by its heat resistance at 550 degrees Fahrenheit, we selected this product as the most heat-resistant oven mitts.
Pros: Comes with a hang loop, eco-friendly, excellent arm protection, cold-proof
Material: Outer material is silicone, fill material is cotton
Dimension: 7.5 x 15 inches
Protect your hands with the most heat-resistant oven mitt on this list, the RED LMLDETA Silicone Oven Hot Mitts. Whether you’re cooking with a cast iron pan, grilling outdoors, or cooking soup, these mitts guarantee full-time protection when in the kitchen.
The RED LMLDETA Silicone Oven Hot Mitts is an eco-friendly food-grade silicone with excellent insulation for handling both hot and cold foods. The mitts have a fabric cuff that is long enough to protect your wrists as well, making them perfect for use when grilling outdoors.
Alongside these qualities, the mitts has a dot texture pattern with a prominent height of 0.8mm to ensure a non-slip grip and a better heat release. The RED LMLDETA company only uses eco-friendly materials. Its inner layer has a recycled cotton filling and a terry fabric lining — both ensure maximum comfort and flexible grip.
Even though the RED LMLDETA Silicone Oven Hot Mitts is a bit overpriced, you get the best value for your money. We won’t choose it as the most heat-resistant oven mitt if it doesn’t do its job right.
Best Slip-Resistance: Gorilla Grip Resistant Silicone Oven Mitts
Due to its flexible silicone and textured honeycomb pattern, we recommend this as the best slip-resistance oven mitts.
Pros: Thick padded lining, no fabric cuff, available in different colors
Cons: No hanging loop
Material: Silicone outer material, polyester fill material
Dimension: 12.5 inches
The Gorilla Grip Resistant Silicone Oven Mitts have the best slip resistance, whether you’re cooking using cast iron cookware or baking cookies in the oven. These oven mitts have a durable and flexible silicone construction.
The Gorilla Grip Resistant Silicone Oven Mitts offer maximum heat protection at 484 degrees Fahrenheit. Along with its product promise as slip-resistant, the extra long mittens have a unique textured honeycomb to promote a natural grip.
Furthermore, you can stay comfortable while cooking thanks to its soft cotton padded lining. The soft cotton lining also offers extra protection from the heat coming from cast iron cookware. What makes it different from most oven mitts out there, its cuffs are not fabric.
Instead, the fabric cuff is also silicone, so you won’t have to worry about the cuff getting dirty or damp. However, a downside of this pair of oven mitts is that it has no hanging loop, so storage can be tricky. Instead of hanging it, you can simply place it directly inside the drawer.
Best One-Size-Fits-All Oven Mitts: GEEKHOM Silicone Oven Mitts
This product has the desirable size, length, and width, and conveniently has finger holes that all one-size-fits-all oven mitts have.
Pros: Long forearm protection, large hanging hole, money-back guarantee policy, fits small to extra large hands
Cons: A bit pricey
Material: Silicone outer material, cotton inner material
Dimension: 12.6 x 5.71 inches
It’s hard to find a one-size-fits-all oven mitten. Some may be too big, and some may be too small. But with the GEEKHOM Silicone Oven Mitts, the product promise of one-size-fits-all mitts won’t let you down.
When you’re handling cast iron cookware, you can expect that it’s heavy and hot. An oven mitt that’s too small may be quite uncomfortable to use. On the contrary, an oven mitt that’s too big may cause slipping, especially when the finger holes are too big.
That’s why the design of GEEKHOM Silicone Oven Mitts, including the finger provisions and overall dimensions, perfectly fits small to extra-large hands. So, your whole family can use these oven mitts — it doesn't matter whether anyone is baking in the oven or grilling outdoors.
In addition to this, it has a heat resistance of up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit. The long sleeve protects your wrist and arms from getting exposed to burns or splatters from boiling water. Of course, you’ll love its large hanging holes for easy storage in the kitchen.
If you’re not completely satisfied with this product, you can inform the manufacturer, and you’ll either get a replacement sent to you or receive a full refund. With the money-back guarantee policy, you’re enjoying a risk-free purchase. But we doubt that you’ll be needing a refund because it’s an excellent oven mitt for cast iron.
Best Value Bundle: IXO 6Pcs Oven Mitts and Pot Holders
This is the 'Best Value' bundle — the package includes a pair of heat-resistant gloves, two pot holders, and two kitchen towels — all with an affordable price tag.
Pros: Great deal for an affordable price, perfect gift idea, all items come with a hanging ring
Cons: Wash by hand only
Material: Silicone and cotton outer material, inner cotton material
Dimension: Oven mitts at 12.99 x 5.91 inches
Why limit yourself to a pair of oven mitts if you can have the whole set of protection for your everyday cooking? You should definitely have the IXO 6Pcs Oven Mitts and Pot Holders. This bundle comes with a pair of silicone oven mitts, two pot holders, and two kitchen towels.
The oven mitts can protect your hands from the cast iron cookware’s heat for up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. Both the pot holders and kitchen towels are of great use when you’re cooking using a cast iron skillet as well.
If you’re too busy cooking and you can’t find your oven mitts anywhere, you can grab the kitchen towel or pot holder and not worry about getting burned. In addition, you’ll love its interior made of soft-quilted cotton for maximum comfort and sweat absorption.
What’s not to love about this value bundle? It’s great protection when cooking with cast iron, or any cookware for that matter. Also, it has a large hanging ring for easy storage. Six items for the price of one? Who wouldn’t love that deal? I know you do!
Buying Guide: Oven Mitts for Cast Iron
Hold on! I know what you’re thinking. Should you click an item and buy it now? Let’s not rush into things and not let compulsive buying control you. Before buying any of the oven mitts listed above, there are a few things you should know.
You need to ask yourself these questions:
- What size oven mitts should I buy?
- What is the best material for oven mitts for cast iron?
- What is the heat resistance of an oven mitt that I should look for?
- Do I go for a long-sleeved cuff or short-sleeved?
- Do I plan to use it for grilling outdoors?
Before buying anything, you should be able to answer these questions. That’s why I came up with this buying guide for oven mitts for cast iron to help you better decide which product is the right one for you. Here’s what you should know.
The first and most important factor you should consider — heat resistance. Cast iron cookware can heat up to between 450 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit on the stovetop or inside the oven. Thus, you’ll need oven mitts that have heat resistance between that range.
If you noticed, I mentioned the heat resistance of all the products above. All are within the safe range of 450 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, except the RED LMLDETA Silicone Oven Gloves with a much higher temperature resistance at 550 degrees Fahrenheit, which is better.
Size and Length
Size and length are another pair of crucial selling points for oven mitts. Oven mitts come in different sizes - small to triple XL to one-size-fits-all. So how will you choose? It’s easy. If your whole family loves to cook, then a one-size-fits-all oven mitt is the best option.
On the other hand, if you’re the only one cooking at home, it’s best to find a product that suits your hand size. Click this link to determine your hand size. What happens if you choose the wrong size?
If it’s too big, it may slip off, but when it’s too small, either it won't fit or you will just hurt your hand if it's too tight a fit. Both situations may lead to unwanted disasters in the kitchen. Do you choose oven mitts with a short cuff or a long cuff? The answer depends on your preference.
The long cuffs offer extra protection to your wrist and arms. Also, you can use long-sleeved oven mitts for grilling as well. Consider it your grill armor. So, if you think about it, long-sleeved oven mitts offer extra protection throughout your cooking journey. Furthermore, look for a product that’s stable and flexible, especially if it’s made of silicone.
Oven Mitt Material
Cast iron cookware is heavy-duty. If you use the wrong oven mitt material when handling cast iron, it can sustain damage to your gloves. What have you noticed with the materials of the products above? Most of them have an exterior silicone construction.
This is because silicone is a durable material that can withstand high heat. Silicone is also the desirable product for oven mitts as it’s easy to clean and is stain-resistant. As for the interior or inner lining, it’s mostly made of cotton. This is to ensure maximum comfort for your hand, so it won’t slip and it will absorb sweat.
The intricate designs or patterns of an oven mitt are not just for aesthetic purposes. It has another purpose - slip avoidance. An oven mitt or pot holder with a smooth texture is prone to slipping and there is a tendency for your cast iron cookware to drop. So, it’s better to buy oven mitts with anti-skid and textured patterns.
Short or Long Cuff?
Oftentimes, you need to pull the cast iron out of the oven. This means part of your wrist or arm gets exposed inside the oven. So, long-cuffed oven mitts would be a better choice to add extra protection to your wrist and arms.
Also, if you purchase a long-cuffed oven mitten, you can use it for grilling as well. So, what’s the bottom line? A long-cuffed oven mitt has more benefits compared to a short-cuffed one. Say goodbye to painful burns when you accidentally bump your hand in the oven rack or even the cast iron handles with long-cuffed oven mitts.
So, the path is clear for you. You have more clarity on what kind of oven mitts you can use for your cast iron cookware. My final words for a Tastylicious cooking is - choose silicone gloves, make sure it has exterior patterns to avoid slipping, and choose long-cuffed oven mitts because they are always a better option.
Furthermore, consider the size and length before buying one. As long as you choose one of the products we recommended above, then you’re making the right choice. Whether you’re cooking with cast iron, stainless steel, or any hot pan, you’re good to go. Have a Tastylicious cooking experience!