Broiling is a cooking process where the food is directly exposed to radiant heat at up to 550 degrees Fahrenheit. It differs from roasting and baking because, with broiling, the heat is directly on top of the food.
Pans that are not broiler-safe may not withstand the high temperature and may end up melting inside your oven. Speaking of heating requirements, you should also look for a broiler pan with even heat distribution and retention.
As for the material? Broiler pans are available in different materials such as aluminum, porcelain, non-stick, alloy steel, and stainless steel. All of which are great materials for broiling, as long as they're marked as broiler-safe.
Along with this, added features of the best broiler pan you should look for are its non-stick coating, the inclusion of a drip tray, it's easy to clean, and its versatile uses aside from broiling. If you're looking for the best broiler pan, you should definitely check out this list.
Table of Contents
- Best Overall: Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler
- Most Versatile Broiler Pan: Range Kleen Broiler Pans
- Best for GE Ovens: GE Genuine OEM Broiler Pan for GE Ovens
- Best for Less Fat Broiling: 3-Piece Set Granite Ware Bake Broiler Pan
- Best Toaster Oven Broiler Pan: G & S OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan and Toaster
- Best for Family Servings: WEZVIX Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
- Widest Cooking Surface: Nordic Ware Large Broiler Pan
- Most Compact Broiler Pan: TeamFar Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
- Most Affordable Broiler Pan: Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
- Best for Whirlpool Broilers: Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan And Grid
- Broiler Pan Buying Guide
- Final Thoughts
Best Overall: Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler
With over 5,000 verified purchases and positive reviews on Amazon, it's undeniable that this best-selling broiler pan should be number on this list.
Pros: Compact, safe for use in toaster ovens, perfectly fits camping and RV stoves
Cons: Not dishwasher-safe
- Length x Width: 10 x 7 inches
- Material: Aluminum
- Finish-type: Non-stick
- Set of: 2-piece set of Roasting Pan and Drip Tray
Broil or bake your favorite meal with the compact and durable Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler. Both the grill pan and drip tray have formed aluminum, which we all know can withstand high heat and is durable.
The Nordic Broiler pan has a non-stick finish, so you won't worry about the food sticking to the pan, and you won't have a hard time cleaning it. We particularly like its compact design, so you can use it in camping or RV stoves.
In addition, we just love this product because you can use it in your toaster oven. The pan is perfect for broiling one steak or baking a couple of crispy bacon strips good for 1-2 persons. This is good, if you don't like cleaning a big broiler pan just to broil one steak, then this is the perfect product for you.
However, a downside to this product is that it's not dishwasher-safe. But don't worry, because you can simply remove the rack and wash the broiler pan with hot and soapy water. DO not use abrasive cleaners or steel wool as this may damage the surface.
Only use a mildly abrasive sponge or a plastic scraper and mild soap to remove the remaining food particles. Even though it's not dishwasher-safe, it's still easy to clean. This is an absolute must-have for every kitchen and even on a camping trip.
Most Versatile Broiler Pan: Range Kleen Broiler Pans
Who wouldn't love a broiler pan that does it all? We know you do, so we bring you the most versatile broiler pan.
Pros: Withstands up to 1025 degrees Fahrenheit, Made in the USA, dishwasher-safe, versatile use, Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) quality
Cons: The cooking surface discolors permanently after a couple of uses.
- Length x Width: 12.75 x 8.5 inches
- Material: Porcelain
- Finish-type: Non-Stick
- Set of: 2-piece set of Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan
What's not to like about the Range Kleen Broiler Pan? Its heavy-duty porcelain construction makes it one of the most durable broiler pans in the market now. Of course, its design can withstand high heat inside the broiler.
The Range Kleen Broiler Pan is an Authentic OEM, which means it has a similar structure to the original broiler pan that comes with your oven. Moreover, it's 'Made in the USA'. Do I need to say more about its durability?
You can crank up your broiler to 1025 degrees Fahrenheit and won't have to worry about a thing. Like the Nordic Ware, the Range Kleen comes in a 2-piece set — a tray with oil draining function and a drip tray serving as a baking pan.
As for its versatility, you can use its grate in outdoor grillers to barbecue meats. Also, you can use the drip tray as a baking pan for pastries, desserts and lasagna, and many more. It's not as compact as the Nordic Broiler pan, but its size is perfect for a smaller oven. It can fit one 12-inch tenderloin or two medium-sized steaks.
In addition, what we love about this broiler pan is its non-stick surface. You won't have to worry about your food sticking to the pan and hassle cleaning. The Range Kleen Broiler pan is easy to clean and dishwasher-safe.
Best for GE Ovens: GE Genuine OEM Broiler Pan for GE Ovens
We know there are a lot of GE oven owners out there, so here we bring you the genuine OEM in case you need a replacement with yours.
Pros: Genuine GE OEM broiler pan, lightweight, compatible with other oven brands,
Cons: Sharp edges
- Length x Width: 16.75 x 12.62 inches
- Material: Enameled steel
- Finish-type: Non-Stick
- Set of: 2-piece set of grill and bottom pan
In case you need a replacement for the broiler pan that comes with your GE oven, you should choose the GE Genuine OEM Broiler Pan for GE Ovens. Why choose something else if you can buy this broiler pan with the exact specifications?
Of course, even if you don't own a GE oven, you can also choose this broiler pan as long as it fits your oven. The package comes with a grill and a bottom pan to catch oil drippings. Both materials are non-stick, durable, and made of premium materials.
It's lightweight, so you won't have a hard time taking it in and out of the broiler. For GE oven owners, make sure to unplug the appliance before installing the broiler pan. As for other types of stoves, you can freely place the pan inside the broiler when you cook.
On the other hand, it has a downside: its sharp edges. That won't be a problem. For as long as you use an oven mitten or potholder, you're okay. All in all, this is a great broiler pan for both GE and non-GE ovens. Nothing beats the original, right?
Best for Less Fat Broiling: 3-Piece Set Granite Ware Bake Broiler Pan
Who wants to eat a steak submerged in its own fatty oil? No one! That's why you should have this broiler pan if you want fewer fats in your protein.
Pros: Drains more fatty oils, non-stick surface, PFOA and PTFE free, dishwasher-safe, used for roasting and baking
Cons: Non-stick coating may chip off when not properly cared for
- Length x Width: 15.75 x 9.88 inches
- Material: Alloy Steel
- Finish-type: Porcelain enamel
- Set of: 3-piece set of broiler/griller pan, roaster pan, and grill rack
With a griller that doubles as a broiler pan, roaster pan, and grill rack that come with the package, you won't have to worry about your meats submerging in their own oily fat. The Granite Ware Bake Broiler Pan's construction is alloy steel, and its finish type is porcelain enamel, which is naturally non-stick.
Unlike other non-stick cookware, it's PFOA and PTFE-free, which we know are harmful chemicals. However, its porcelain enamel finish may chip if not properly taken care of. Make sure never to drop the broiler pan and wash it properly, as stated in the product manual.
Another thing we love about this broiler pan is its perfect size for cooking small meals. You can cook enough servings for the whole family without struggling too much with cleaning big cookware.
It's not so bad for its price, especially since you can use it for roasting, baking, and grilling. You can use the grill pan on your gas or charcoal grill. Just remember not to use any piece of the set in a glass cooktop.
Best Toaster Oven Broiler Pan: G & S OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan and Toaster
If you want a broiler pan that also fits your toaster oven, then we recommend this product for you.
Pros: Perfectly fits toaster ovens, DuraGlide Plus non-stick coating, best for single-serving meals
Cons: Not dishwasher-safe
- Length x Width: 8.5 x 6.5 inches
- Material: Alloy Steel
- Finish-type: Duraglide PLUS Non-stick Finish
- Set of: one bake and roast pan to catch oil drippings and a Fat-A-Way broil pan
Everybody wants a product with versatile uses, so you'll surely love the G & S OvenStuff Nonstick Broiler Pan and Toaster where you can use it in the broiler or toaster oven. It's the perfect size to create a meal of 1-2 servings.
What we love the most about this product is the Fat-A-Way broil pan. Healthy cooking is made easy with this broiler pan to eliminate excess fats from foods like bacon, steak, and chicken. Furthermore, thanks to its DuraGlide Plus non-stick coating, you won't need to use a cooking spray, which is a healthier option.
Its quality alloy steel construction may have a heavy weight, but this ensures even heat distribution and resistance when broiling. Thanks to its quality steel construction, you never have to worry about burnt edges on your broiler pan.
This product is proudly made in the USA, and the G & S Metal Products Company is committed to the quality, value, and quality construction in every cookware they make. Needless to say, they keep their company promise with this broiler pan.
Best for Family Servings: WEZVIX Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
Measuring at 12.4 x 9.6 inches, this is the best broiler pan for 4-to-6-person family servings.
Pros: Chemical-free, dishwasher-safe, shiny mirror finished surface, simple design
Cons: Not non-stick
- Length x Width: 12.4 x 9.6 inches
- Material: Stainless steel
- Finish-type: None
- Set of: Set of 2 - wire rack and baking tray
With the many designs and colors of broiler pans, nothing beats a classic stainless steel design brought to you by the WEZVIX Stainless Steel Broiler Pan. Let's go back to the basics where a broiler pan does not contain any chemical coating for healthier cooking.
What's not to love about the WEZVIX Stainless Steel Broiler Pan? It has a shiny finished surface for easy cleaning. The smooth tray doesn't have any rough spots, so you can easily release foods from the cooking surface. Although it doesn't have a nonstick coating, it's okay. You can simply use small amounts of cooking spray.
In addition, its rolled rims make it easier for you to hold the broiler pan. Also, you won't ever have to struggle with cleaning this broiler pan as it's dishwasher safe, or you can hand wash it if you prefer.
It's the perfect size for serving food for a family of 4-6 persons. When buying a broiler pan, you definitely have to consider the serving size you can prepare in one cooking. Nobody wants two or three rounds of cooking because it's all their broiler pan can accommodate, right?
Lastly, we love the versatility of this basic broiler pan. Aside from broiling, you can use it for baking, roasting, and as a cooling rack. Nothing beats the classic broiler pan like the WEZVIX Stainless Steel Broiler Pan.
Widest Cooking Surface: Nordic Ware Large Broiler Pan
Measuring at 15 x 9.9 inches, this is the best-rated broiler pan with the widest cooking surface.
Pros: Best for broiling large servings, non-stick surface, dishwasher-safe
Cons: A bit heavy at 2.5 pounds
- Length x Width: 15 x 9.9 inches
- Material: Aluminized Steel
- Finish-type: Non-stick
- Set of: Set of 2 - broiling rack and drip pan
Another great contender as the best broiler pan is yet again from Nordic Ware, the Nordic Ware Large Broiler Pan. But this time, we're bringing you one of the best broiler pans with the widest cooking surface.
So if you love hosting dinner parties or serving large meals for your big family, this is the best choice for you. Both the broiling rack and drip pan have an aluminized steel construction with a non-stick finish. Don't worry about excess grease accumulating in the broiler rack, as it has holes on both sides.
We know it's tiring to scrub a big broiler pan. That’s why we love this product — because it's easy to clean. Food particles won't get stuck on the cooking surface thanks to its non-stick surface. And the best part? It's dishwasher-safe.
Cook healthy and delicious meals for your big family or your many guests coming over with this Nordic Ware Large Broiler Pan. Convenience, versatility, and durability are what Nordic Ware cookware can offer.
Most Compact Broiler Pan: TeamFar Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
Measuring at 9x7 inches, this is the best compact broiler pan on the market now.
Pros: Compact size, dishwasher-safe, fits toaster ovens
Cons: No non-stick coating
- Length x Width: 9 x 7 inches
- Material: Stainless steel
- Finish-type: None
- Set of: 2-piece set - Broiler rack and drip tray
Another classic stainless steel broiler pan that's compact is the TeamFar Stainless Steel Broiler Pan. If you have a small oven at home or only need to cook for 1-2 persons, then this is an excellent choice.
The TeamFar Stainless Steel Broiler Pan has durable stainless steel construction and no chemical finish. Not having a non-stick coating is not a bad quality at all. You get to avoid instances of toxic leaching and chemical chips in your food. Hence, you have the peace of mind of only eating healthy foods.
If you choose this product, not only are you buying an excellent broiler pan, but a pan for toasting, baking, and roasting as well. Furthermore, it's a great replacement for Teflon pans and disposable aluminum foil pans. What's not to love about a bakeware set that does it all?
This is the perfect broiler pan for controlling your food proportions. What can you broil in this product? Almost anything - burger, sausage, chicken wings, steak, and many more. Additionally, this is another ideal broiler pan you can use during your RV or camping trips.
Most Affordable Broiler Pan: Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan
If you're on a budget, we recommend this broiler pan. You don't need to break the bank to have a quality broiler pan.
Pros: Affordable, dishwasher-safe, versatile product
Cons: Not non-stick
- Length x Width: 12.25 x 9.5 inches
- Material: Stainless Steel
- Finish-type: None
- Set of: 2-piece set of broiling grate and bottom tray
Cook your family-friendly meals with the ultimately durable Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan. You can use its bottom tray separately for baking and roasting, that's why we love the versatility of this product.
It has the perfect size to broil two steaks, bake cookies for the whole family, and roast some vegetables. This sturdy, stainless steel broiling pan withstands high temperatures inside the broiler.
Also, both the bottom tray and broiling grate are dishwasher-safe. Just make sure to soak it in warm water before placing it inside the dishwasher. By doing this, not only are you saving time in cleaning, but you're preserving its shiny finish as well.
Most importantly, the Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan is pretty much affordable. For its low price tag, you're getting similar qualities to a high-grade stainless steel broiler pan. Given these points, it's definitely worth including in this list of the best broiler pans.
Best for Whirlpool Broilers: Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan And Grid
If you need a replacement for your Whirlpool broiler pan, we recommend this product to you.
Pros: Whirlpool Factory Certified Accessory, non-stick feature, fast and even heat distribution, 30-Day Return Policy
Cons: A bit heavy
- Length x Width: 16.75 x 12.75 inches
- Material: Heavy duty porcelain
- Finish-type: Enameled porcelain coating
- Set of: 2-piece set of a broiler pan and roasting rack
The Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan And Grid is the Factory Certified Accessory manufactured by Whirlpool. This is the replacement for the original broiler pan that comes with your Whirlpool oven. Apart from this, it's also compatible with other oven broilers.
The Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan package contains one premium broiler pan and one roasting rack. Both of which are dishwasher-safe and have versatile uses other than broiling. You can use it for baking, roasting, and as a cooling rack as well.
What we love about this product is there are no tools required for the installation process. It has the perfect size for a broiler pan and fits most standard ovens. Even though it's dishwasher-safe, it wipes off easily and is washed by hand without any hassle.
The roasting rack has vent-type holes specifically designed to drain oil and juices away from the food. Also, to allow the air to circulate around the food completely. This is all while preventing food splatter and smoking while broiling.
Broiler Pan Buying Guide
It's tricky to buy a broiler pan if you don't know what characteristics to look for. To make a better buying decision, you should compare these products based on their important features and aspects. Here's what you should know:
Before anything else, when buying a broiler pan, make sure that it fits with your oven broiler or toaster oven at home. That's why we placed the size dimensions of the pan on each product review so you can ensure that it fits your appliance at home.
Additionally, you should consider the serving size you can cook at a time. How many people are you cooking for most of the time? If you cook for 4-6 persons, you should get a bigger broiler pan like the WEZVIX Stainless Steel Broiler Pan.
Furthermore, if you love hosting dinner parties, choose the broiler pan with the widest cooking surface like the Nordic Ware Large Broiler Pan. If you live by yourself or cook for two people most of the time, you can go for the more compact designs like the TeamFar Stainless Steel Broiler Pan or the Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler. Because at the end of the day, you don't want to be cleaning a large broiler pan but only cooking for one person, right?
A broiler pan should have a heavy-duty construction. Grilling and broiling are similar, but they are different. With grilling, the heat source is under the food. On the other hand, with broiling, the heat source is directly on top of the food.
Inside the broiler, the temperature can reach up to 550 degrees Fahrenheit with direct heat exposure. So a broiler pan should have a heavy-duty construction. Some of the durable materials of broiler pans are stainless steel, porcelain, aluminum, enameled steel, and alloy steel.
Of course, a broiler pan should have a heavy-duty performance. It should last for a long-time because you don't want a broiler pan you'll only dispose of after several uses, right? It's easy for a company to guarantee durability, but how can you legitimately check on a product's durability?
It's better to read consumer reviews, especially on Amazon. Nothing beats the first-hand experience of actual buyers. With Amazon Verified Purchase, buyers can change their initial review. This is where you'll usually see honest reviews, most especially on the product's durability.
Should you choose a broiler pan with non-stick properties or not? Well, there are its downsides and advantages. If you choose a broiler pan with a non-stick coating, you won't need a cooking oil spray. However, non-stick broiler pans are prone to leaching and rusting.
As for broiler pans without a non-stick surface, it does the opposite. So it has its pros and cons. Which one should you choose? Both are fine as long as you follow the proper care instructions of the product.
Maintenance and Easy-to-Clean
Which broiler pan do you prefer? Something you can toss inside the dishwasher? Then you should choose a dishwasher-safe broiler pan. If you don't have a dishwasher at home or don't mind the extra time cleaning, then you can choose the opposite.
For as long as the broiler pan is easy to clean, then it's an excellent choice. However, many kitchen experts suggest that handwashing any cookware will contribute to its longevity.
There are a lot of broiler pans with versatile uses. Other than broiling, it's an advantage if you can use it for baking, grilling, roasting, or as a cooling tray. If you think you're going to have a lot of uses for your broiler pan other than broiling, then choose a product with versatile uses. It's a good idea to get the best out of your money by buying a broiler pan with multi-purpose traits.
That's all you need to know if you plan to buy a broiler pan. We hope you learned valuable information and important aspects to look for when buying a broiler pan by reading this post.
Our team will always strive to help you with informed buying decisions to have the best cookware in your kitchen. As long as you follow our recommendations, you are guaranteed to buy the best broiler pan.
Leave a Reply